One Pie Pizza Co

Wow. What more can I say than that? This is by far one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The crust was incredible, the sauce was unbelievable, and the pepperoni was perfect. No dine in option, but that's okay because it's that good. One tip I would add is that I'll get extra sauce next time. It was a decent amount, but by the time I got home over an hour away the crust had soaked up some of the sauce. I obviously had a slice there when I picked it up, so I could tell a difference.

Recently had a pizza that was not up to usual quality but the owner/manager reached out to me to replace it. It was excellent. Sometimes isolated incidents slip by and that is understandable. Thank you for your high quality food and we will remain a loyal customer and urge all else to patronize your fine quality foods you offer. Thank you so very much!!!!! Pizza excellent ? ?

Simple pepperoni with onions and black olives was perfect. Onions slightly charred. 5 Stars. The Pizza of the Month (Sweet Chili Pineapple & Bacon) was not a hit and threw most away. Stick to a basic pizza and you'll enjoy it.

We ordered One Pie Pizza breakfast pizzas for a catered breakfast event. They were super easy to work with, the delivery was smooth and on time. And the pizza was fantastic! Even their gluten free crust was great. Incredibly pleased with the whole experience.

First timer. Friend recommended. Very good. Cooked very well. Sauce was semi sweet and delicious great cup n char. Great cheese. Looks like it could have been overcooked but the dough and crust was perfect for my taste. Little bit on the softer side. Ordered online. Picked up at the desired time

As always, One Pie does not disappoint! We had the Allen goat pizza this time and I stuffed one last slice down just to taste it!!!! Great Pizza! Friendly staff on time and perfect.

Top notch pizza. Consistent, delicious, real cheese , great sauce.. love everything about this place. We come all the way from the Roc

If you are stopping into Buffalo for your first time then i definitely recommend this place. My girlfriend and I love spice so we got the Cherry Bomb Pizza which was AMAZING and hot. Gotta love the blue cheese best i’ve ever had! Pricey btw but very good quality!